Books vs enchanted items — which is actually cheaper?
Book multipliers are roughly half of item multipliers, so the same enchantment transferred from a book costs about half as much per operation. But merging books is a longer chain, and chains accumulate penalties. The honest answer depends on how many enchantments you're stacking.
The multiplier gap
From the Wiki's table (full list on the XP table):
| Enchantment | From item | From book |
|---|---|---|
| Sharpness, Efficiency, Protection, Power, Unbreaking | 1× | 1× |
| Fire Aspect, Looting, Fortune, Mending, most utility | 4× | 2× |
| Thorns, Silk Touch, Infinity, Channeling, Soul Speed | 8× | 4× |
Note the 1× tier: for the most common enchantments the book advantage is zero on multiplier. The saving there comes from the item route's other cost — destroying a second enchanted item you had to find or trade for.
When the item route wins
- One or two enchantments on a cheap item. Two merges total means penalties never stack; the extra multiplier is smaller than the effort of sourcing and merging books.
- You already have the donor item and don't care about it.
- Very high levels. A Sharpness V book costs 1 × 5 = 5 — same as the item. When the multiplier is equal, fewer operations wins.
When books win
- Stacking four or more enchantments. Books let you build the combine tree deliberately; items force the penalties onto your target early.
- The 4×/8× tier. Half-price per transfer is real money at those multipliers.
- Sourcing. Librarians sell specific books; the item you'd need to destroy for the same enchantment may not exist in your world.
The hybrid that most players actually want
Build the first two enchantments from items if you have donors, then finish the item with books arranged by the calculator. Or simpler: use books for everything and let the tool balance the tree — the difference is usually a handful of levels, and the plan is far less error-prone.
Either way, run the plan through the calculator before touching the anvil: the cheapest route depends on the set of enchantments, not on a universal rule.